Friday, November 25
I watched Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire on opening night, but it took me a while to wrap my head around what I thought of it. My first impression was that it was a fine movie. It was well acted, the script was pretty good, it was undoubtedly gorgeous, and even the action scenes were a lot of fun. But there was something missing. The way I've been putting this to friends is that the movie didn't have a soul.
The reason I had to let this stuff stew for a while is I wanted to be more specific than that. Saying a movie doesn't have a soul is kind of hard to quantify, and I feel like it might be unfair to the movie. Yes, the movie wasn't perfect. It was sometimes a bit too goofy for my tastes. And it would do mood swings way to fast without some kind of transition. This is the first Harry Potter story that has some truly dark stuff in it, and going from light hearted comedy to dark material and back again is a little jarring to the mood. Don't get me wrong, tension breaking comedy is important, but that's not really what this was for me. But in the end those are minor gripes. Overall it's a good movie. But it just lacked that something that can make a movie memorable and great. It lacked a soul.