Wednesday, May 31
Watching Brokeback Mountain was strange for me. I think it suffered for all the expectations surrounding it. This is a slow, methodical movie that I think really depends on giving yourself over to it. The kind of movie where the pacing is a deliberate part of the style and feel of the movie, almost like another character (or at the very least, a significant part of the exposition.) The trouble is with all the talk about what a breakthrough film it is and all the Oscar chatter I'm not letting myself just watch the movie, instead I'm waiting to see this amazing breakthrough movie everyone keeps talking about.
I think I broke through most of that after the first hour or so, but in a way it was already too late at that point. I think I kind of missed the artistry of the movie because I was spending too much time thinking about it (heh, what's new about that?)
A key theme to this movie is that these characters have a deep inner desire to be with each other, but feel that they can't because of how society will judge them. There's an element of tragedy to this, but I didn't really see it as any different from other similar stories of forbidden love. Yeah, they're gay. So what? Maybe it's just that I don't find the concept of gay relationships strange, so I don't feel they really get a special pass. The movie isn't ground breaking for me in that sense because we all know there are gay folk around and we all know that societies have traditionally judged them very harshly. It just feels smug to hail this as some kind of monumental gay rights film. It's not like people who are prejiduced against gays will watch this and all of a sudden connect with people who at a deep core feel attraction to the their own gender. I will give them that it's a well made drama about a place and a time and some people in a tragic situation, but I didn't see any kind of groundbreaking civil rights stuff.
What I did see is the two main characters destroy the lives of all kinds of people around them because the didn't feel they could live the lives they wanted to. And yeah, that sucked for them, but I don't have a ton of sympathy because at the end of the day they were still willfully living a lie that was destroying the lives of the people close to them. Gay or straight, that's not cool with me.
It actually made most of the characters pretty unlikable for me. The only person I really cheered for was Ennis' wife. She was the only person who really took control and made the best of a bad situation.
I did think the dichotomy of scenery was kind of neat. There are many gorgeous, peaceful scenes in this movie, and they're all when the cowboys are up in the mountains and able to be with each other. The rest of the movie when they're stuck in society has a drab and downtrodden style. That was good, and not too heavy handed. But the scene at the end with the closet was just laugh out loud heavy handed symbolism for me.
I really do think this is a better movie than my reaction here portrays. Like I said, I think it's just suffering from the meaning's people have attached to it. However, regardless of all that I have no problems with Crash winning best picture this year. Brokeback Mountain is a fine movie, but as far as I'm concerned Crash was clearly better.